Introduction
Today we are going to check out a RuneScape inspired idle game named Melvor Idle. It is a unique idle game that caught my attention with its promising blend of role-playing elements and idle mechanics. As a fan of both genres, I was eager to dive into this pixelated world of adventure and progression. There is only an absent story with lore and books, but no narrative at all, thus there will not be a story section in this review.
What did I think before playing Melvor Idle?
Before playing, I was intrigued by the positive buzz surrounding Melvor Idle within the gaming community. The concept of an idle game with deep RPG elements seemed appealing, but I wondered if it could truly deliver a satisfying experience without sacrificing the core aspects of both genres. My anticipation was cautiously optimistic, and I entered the game with an open mind. Without further ado, I went to check out the Steam Page.
The Steam Page
https://store.steampowered.com/app/1267910/Melvor_Idle/
The Steam page provided a comprehensive overview of Melvor Idle’s features, showcasing a vast array of skills, monsters, and a promising progression system. The pixel art style added a nostalgic touch, reminiscent of classic RPGs. The overwhelmingly positive reviews further heightened my expectations, setting the stage for an engaging experience.
Rating
I rated Melvor Idle with an 8.2 before playing.
I always liked RuneScape, I also like idle games. This seemed like a great game!
Gameplay
Melvor Idle’s gameplay is where it shines. The game seamlessly integrates idle mechanics with a vast skill system, providing a sense of accomplishment even when not actively playing. It is handy to note that unless you use mods, you can only AFK for 24 hours. This means you do need to check with the game.
The diverse range of skills, activities, and monsters to engage with keeps the gameplay fresh and rewarding. The progression system is well balanced, thus encouraging strategic decision making. You will need many skills to get further with another skill, this will lead you down a rabbit hole, most likely into a new addiction.
If you enjoyed RuneScape, then you know there are pets, these are also in this game. They all give different bonuses. A fun thing is, that almost all the items from RuneScape are in this game, if you wanted a RuneScape without walking, then I think you might have found what you are looking for.
Rating
I rated the gameplay of Melvor Idle with a 7.7
This game can get highly addictive!
Sound and Graphics
Graphics
The pixel art style, though nostalgic, may not appeal to everyone. However, the simplicity of the graphics contributes to the game’s charm. It is all is simple, and easy. There is a wide selection of enemies to beat up though, and with the DLC, a whole map to discover!
Rating
I rated the graphics of Melvor Idle with a 6.5
I did not rate the sounds, since there is no sound in this game.
What did I think after playing Melvor Idle?
After spending considerable time in Melvor Idle, my initial optimism was validated. The game successfully merges idle and RPG elements, offering a satisfying balance of progress and engagement. The depth of the skill system, coupled with frequent updates.
Rating
I rated Melvor Idle with an 8.4 after playing.
Down the rabbit hole we go!
What are my personal thoughts about Melvor Idle?
Melvor Idle provides an enjoyable blend of idle and RPG elements, offering a unique and rewarding experience for fans of both genres.
Rating
My personal Rating of Melvor Idle is a 8
Last Words
Pros
- Engaging idle gameplay with deep RPG elements.
- Vast skill system and progression mechanics.
- Active developer support and regular updates.
- Strategic decision-making enhances gameplay.
- Well-balanced progression system.
Cons
- Lack of a traditional narrative may disappoint some players.
- Pixel art style may not appeal to everyone.
- Learning curve for newcomers to the idle or RPG genre.
- No sound
Melvor Idle successfully captures the essence of both idle and RPG genres, providing an engaging experience for fans of incremental games. While it may not cater to those seeking a narrative-driven adventure, its rich gameplay, depth, and active development make it a standout title in the idle gaming space. Whether you’re a seasoned idle gamer or new to the genre, Melvor Idle offers a rewarding journey worth embarking on.
The Final Rating
7.7
Please let me know what you think of Melvor Idle in the comments!
I hope you enjoyed reading this review, I hope to see you in the next review!
If you liked reading this review, maybe you would like to share this review with your friends.
Jaromir Krzyszczak
Idlers are just not for me
Wonder
I was curious about the buzz surrounding this one, so thanks for covering it! It sounds like a unique idle game that is much more to my style!
supersven
It is a very complex but fun game!
jon doe
not bad for an idle game. might check it out
supersven
It does not even have microtransactions!
Quean
One of the decent idle games out there. Thank you for reviewing it.
supersven
You are welcome!
Lucky
👍
metalhead8489
i'm really not into idlers, i find them boring
rezonono
I wasn't too excited by the interface but your review makes me want to try it out. It's an interesting and original approach.
DonCarlos
The great thing that I love about this game is the fact that it has no microtransactions so everyone is on the same playing field. I havent seen idle game like this beforehand.
supersven
It also has no sound!
Пленгей Ілля
The game is not really for me, but it was interesting to read.
Maybe I'll try
long shade
Good review!
supersven
Thank you!
fano23
Looks like a cool game, didn't see it before
lngIhmr
👍 Nice review!
Panagiotis Kougioumtzis
Thank you very much for your efforts! <3
Myr
The colours and the minimalistic design make it look like a user interface from work.
John
I will play it!
EMPERORU
not regular idler game (visuals)
Valky
The game has no sound? Interesting indeed
supersven
It seriously has no sound.
Javier del Ríos
The graphics are fine, but no sound, really?
supersven
Yeah, really!
RaR
Looks interesting for an idler game.
Delicious Bacon
"you can only AFK for 24 hours. This means you do need to check with the game."
Yep, it feels like 4X game. Or some of those old browser games before idle games were mainstream - where you'd click your stuff and go away until your jobs get done.
supersven
If you use a mod, you can afk forever!
Alan
No story? Then I doubt that I should try this game. Thanks for this review!
supersven
There is a bit of lore to be found, but that is all!
dharmang
thank you